Midge Fishing for Winter Trout

Cold water, a tiny fly, and one rig you can see.

From the book Fly Fishing for Nerds — $9.74 →

Quick setup

  1. 5-weight, 6X tippet, one size 18 zebra midge, small indicator about 1.5 times the depth.
  2. Soft side of a slow lane. Dead drift. A handful of drifts that track.
  3. If midges are on the water, switch to a Griffith's Gnat and take the indicator off. One change.

What you need

A size 18 zebra midge for a quiet surface, a Griffith's Gnat when you can see the bugs, 6X to tie them on, and a small indicator you can watch.

  • Black zebra midge assortment, sizes 14–18 The Fly Fishing Place

    Nine black bead-head zebra midges, three each of sizes 14, 16, and 18. The North Carolina chart's winter sizes start at 18, so start there. The bead is the weight. This fly goes under the indicator, not under the Griffith's Gnat.

    Buy on Amazon

  • Griffith's Gnat assortment, sizes 16–22 Region Fishing

    Twelve Griffith's Gnats, three each of sizes 16, 18, 20, and 22. Orvis describes the fly as a midge or a cluster of midges. Start at 20 if you cannot match a bug in your hand.

    Buy on Amazon

  • RIO Powerflex tippet, 6X RIO

    One 30-yard spool of nylon 6X, 0.005 inches. The tippet guide's size for a hook 18. A size 20 divides to about 6.7, so this page still starts here.

    Buy on Amazon

  • Oros small strike indicator, chartreuse Oros

    Three small chartreuse screw-on foam indicators. Lock one on the leader above the tippet knot, where the leader is still thick.

    Buy on Amazon

The button goes to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Disclosure

1. Why midges matter in cold water

The winter guide starts when the river is in the 30s or the 40s: a short afternoon, slow water, and small flies. This page is which small fly, and how to rig it. The water-temperature guide is how to take the reading. The time-of-day guide is why that cold band is a short session, not a dawn start.

In southeastern Minnesota, winter midges are a real food, not a guess from the month. A project funded by the Minnesota Environment and Natural Resources Trust Fund reports that winter-emerging aquatic insects, primarily chironomids, the midge family, are a locally abundant and critical food for trout in the streams that project studied. Minnesota Trout Unlimited describes the same groundwater streams: those midges keep growing, emerging, and reproducing in the coldest months, while many other aquatic insects are in diapause, not growing or emerging. That is one region. It is a reason to look for midges when your river is cold. It is not a count of the insects in your run.

Use the same loop as the observe page. The temperature, the hour, and whether you can see bugs are the observation. One sentence about the lane and the fly is the hypothesis. A handful of drifts that actually track is the test.

2. When they show, and where the river stays open

The North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission hatch chart lists midges, true flies in the order Diptera, from January through March, in the afternoon, in sizes 18–24. The patterns it names are a gray or olive midge, a Griffith's Gnat, and a Renegade. That calendar is North Carolina's. The bugs over your run are the check. If you can catch one, the size comes from the insect in your hand, not from the chart.

Afternoon is the overlap with the winter guide. Idaho Fish and Game, as that page cites them, says winter fish are not feeding hard until mid- to late morning, and that on a sunny day they are most active in mid-afternoon. If the surface stays quiet through that window, stay with the nymph. If you see the bugs, fish them. A dark start, in water near freezing, tests an hour those pages are not using.

Not every river is in the 30s on the same day. Virginia DWR, writing about the South Fork of the Holston, says limestone springs keep that river's temperature more even than the creeks around it: the coldest water in summer and the warmest in winter. On that river, stoneflies, midges, and mayfly nymphs are the prominent subsurface insects, and sporadic afternoon blue quills and blue-winged olives are the dry-fly hatch. Those olives are the winter guide's other row. This page is the midge. Your spring creek is a different rock. The thermometer is the check.

A tailwater is the other place to measure before you decide the week is over. USGS says that in winter some lake surfaces get very cold, and the deeper water, which holds a steadier temperature through the year, is then warmer than the surface. The same page describes Cougar Dam, whose main release sits low in the reservoir, so the dam draws that deeper water. The release USGS charts there is the cold summer one. In winter, that same deeper layer is the water that has not matched the air. The winter guide is why the first mile below a dam can still be open when the freestone above it is not. If it is open, take the temperature. If the reading is in the 30s or 40s, you are still on this page. If the reach is shelf ice, do not force it.

3. A zebra midge, a Griffith's Gnat, and 6X

Two flies. Fish one of them.

A zebra midge is a slim bead-head nymph for the larva and the pupa, the stages under the surface. The nine in the box are black, three each of sizes 14, 16, and 18, from The Fly Fishing Place. The North Carolina chart's winter sizes start at 18. Start with the 18. The bead is the weight, so leave the split shot off until a few drifts show the fly is not getting down. The 16, and then the 14, are later. They are a size change, after the 18 has had a real chance.

Orvis describes the Griffith's Gnat as a dry that imitates a midge or a cluster of midges. George Griffith, a founder of Trout Unlimited, tied it. The dozen in the box is three each of sizes 16, 18, 20, and 22, from Region Fishing. The chart's range is 18–24, so start at 20 if you cannot match a bug in your hand, or at 18 or 22 if you can see the size. The 16 is the one you can see when a 20 disappears on the glare. It is not the first fly on a flat you can already see.

Tippet follows the fly. The tippet guide divides the hook size by 3. A size 18 is 6X, and 6X on that chart is 0.005 inches. A size 20 divides to about 6.7, between 6X and 7X. This page starts on 6X, the same spool the winter guide uses for a size 20. The spool in the box is one 30-yard roll of nylon 6X. Tie it to the thin tip of the leader, the way the knots guide ties tippet on. Stay within one X of that tip. A 5X leader takes 5X or 6X. A jump from 4X to 6X hinges, and the fly turns over badly. On 6X the improved clinch wants six or seven wet turns. A dry cinch is how this tippet slips.

Cut about two feet for a dry, or for a nymph in ordinary depth. On the indicator, the tippet is also the depth. If the fly needs to ride deeper than two feet, cut the length the depth calls for. The tippet guide is that exception.

4. An indicator, or a dry

Pick the rig from what you can see. Do not fish both in the first ten minutes.

Quiet surface. One zebra midge under an indicator. The indicator guide is where the float goes and what a take looks like. Put the small indicator on the leader, above the tippet knot, where the leader is still thick enough to hold it. A float that slides down the 6X has changed your depth before the drift starts. A workable first depth is about one and a half times the water you think you are fishing. In water around knee-deep, that is roughly two to three feet from indicator to fly. Cast upstream of the spot so the fly has time to sink. The bead is the weight. Add one small shot only after those drifts show the fly never gets down, and put it a few inches above the fly, not on the hook.

Midges in the air, or dimples on a flat. The Griffith's Gnat, alone, on the same 6X. No indicator. The fly has to land upright and drift with the bubbles. A wake means that cast did not count. The dry-dropper guide is the rig with a nymph hung under a dry, and it is the wrong first cast here. That page keeps the dropper short, and it keeps a heavy bead off the dry, because the dry sinks and you have tested neither fly. A bead-head zebra under a Griffith's Gnat is that failure. Fish the gnat by itself. If you later want a nymph a foot under a dry that can still float, build it on the dry-dropper page, with a nymph light enough to leave the dry up.

The rod is the 9-foot 5-weight on the first-rod guide, with the floating line. Midges do not need a second rod. Nylon for the tippet. The knots guide is why the improved clinch slips on fluorocarbon.

5. Fish one lane

  1. Take the temperature in the moving water you will fish. Write it down. If it is not in the 30s or the 40s, you may be on the winter guide's edge, or off this page entirely. The thermometer decides. The chart does not.
  2. Pick one lane before you pick the second fly. The soft side of a seam, the deep bucket, the inside of a bend where the surface is slower. The reading-water guide is the walk. The fast riffle you fished in June is a poor first test when the water is this cold. The winter guide's reason is the same: trout in this band are not chasing.
  3. If the surface is quiet, fish the zebra under the indicator. Mend once so the float travels with the bubbles beside it. A float that races is drag. That drift did not test the fly.
  4. Set when the indicator does something the current did not. It pauses while the bubbles keep going. It twitches, slips sideways, or dips and stays down. A short, smooth lift is enough. A hard sweep on 6X breaks the tippet, or pulls the fly away from the fish. Rocks repeat. Fish do not. If every supposed take is the bottom, shorten, and run the same lane again.
  5. If you see midges, or dimples, stop. Clip the zebra off, tie on the Griffith's Gnat, and take the indicator off the leader. Give that fly its own handful of drifts. The thing that changed is the rig. Leave the lane alone for those casts, so you can say which change mattered.
  6. Stand where your line and your shadow do not land on the lane first. Footing still comes first. Shelf ice is not a step. Safety is the first item on the bank checklist.

6. When it goes wrong

Change one thing, then repeat the same drift.

The drifts drag. Mend, or cast shorter. Keep the same fly and the same depth. A dragging drift tested the line, not the pattern.

The fly never ticks in a slot that should be deep. Lengthen the distance from indicator to fly. Do not also change the size. If the new depth is clean and empty, then change the fly, or walk to the next slow lane. Not both.

You snag on every pass. Shorten. A fly in the sticks is not a refusal.

The Griffith's Gnat sinks or cuts a wake. Dry it, and check that you did not leave the zebra hanging from it. A bead-head nymph under that dry is an indicator rig that lost its indicator. Take the nymph off, or go back to the indicator and fish the zebra there. Do not dress the nymph, and do not grease the tippet that is supposed to sink.

It tangles. False cast once, with an open loop. Nip the tags. A wind knot is a small loop you did not tie. Cut it and retie. Fishing the knot is how 6X breaks on a fish.

You break off, or the knot slips. The turns were dry, or the tippet was nicked. Wet the clinch and pull it before the fly goes back in. Do not solve a slipped knot by stepping up to 4X in the same cast you change flies. Thicker tippet is a different test, and on a size 18 it is the test the tippet guide saves for when you can see the tippet and the fish are refusing a clean drift. That is a later change. Name it.

Nothing eats. First ask whether the drifts tracked. If they did, change the size one step: 18 to 20 on the gnat, or 18 to 16 on the zebra. If you walk to the next lane, fish the same fly for the first handful of casts, so the new water is the thing that changed. Two changes in one cast leave you unable to say which one mattered.

One line in your phone: the temperature, whether you saw midges, the fly, the size, the depth, and whether the drifts tracked. After a few afternoons you can see whether you only ever fish the size 14 in water that was showing you a size 20.

The short afternoon, the slow lane, and this loop get more room in Fly Fishing for Nerds: A Data-Driven Guide to Finding, Hooking, and Landing Trout. Readers can take 25% off ($9.74) with code NERDS25 at Leanpub.

The Riverbank Checklist is the one-page routine for the bank: safety first, then one hypothesis and a short test. Temperature, the fly, and the depth belong in that note.

Get the book

  • Title Fly Fishing for Nerds: A Data-Driven Guide to Finding, Hooking, and Landing Trout
  • Author Douglas Rothchester
  • Format Ebook, 186 pages
  • Price $9.74 on Leanpub · $12.99 on Gumroad

The Leanpub link already includes code NERDS25. Gumroad sells the same ebook for $12.99.

Related guides